Bosa's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Children's Overture]

I enjoyed this piece. I can see Don Quixote de la Mancha riding onwards to some fabricated adventure while listening to this. I really don't have much to say because the song is simple at what it does and its style is obvious, so there's no need for me to tell you something you already know.

I never criticize someone by the programs they use or the quality of their production, but I can't help but point out one simple flaw in this song. At 1:37 and on, the excitement that I'm sure you're wanting to build is cut in half by the quality of the samples used here. I'm pretty sure I know which program you used at this point, so I know the limitations you are restricted to. But don't let such things discourage you. I was furious at the ending of my song (which was non-existent) but the amount of effort and devotion that was poured into the music is what matters the most, whether the listeners/judges are aware of it or not.

As long as you and I continue to do our best to lift other people up instead of ourselves, we will be rewarded greatly. I'm sure you agree that this website could use some direction, and the more your music expresses selfless, devoted, and hard work, the better the reward. People on this site appreciate good quality work, and we can use that to our advantage.

But anyways, I really enjoyed this song. I'll keep in touch.

BlazingDragon responds:

The Don Quixote image fits the piece very well. I hadn't thought of that. :)

Unfortunately, the deadline forced me to write the ending in about ten minutes. It didn't turn out as I had wanted, and the brass samples from EastWest just can't pull off what I hear internally. I'll go back and fix the ending when I finish this piece though.

I agree with your sentiment about hard work and lifting other people up. It is a goal for me to write music that inspires people or otherwise makes them experience emotion and feel more alive.

Thank you, Bosa.

[Chemicals [NGADM]]

I could sit here and listen to this for hours, and I'm being literal. I honestly don't know what else to say... I'm just too amazed by this song.

Kor-Rune responds:

Thank you! I really appreciate that you can stand more than one listen! I will polish this more in time, but I'm glad you like it now!

Thanks again for the review!

[Kristberg Fields]

You know, I never look at someone's sound programs as a deciding factor in my reviews. But I must say, at the beginning I honestly had the feeling that I was sitting in front of a royal string ensemble, but before I realized I was in front of the computer, I thought I would take advantage of the moment and enjoy the comfort of my kingly baroque throne.

But anyways, I wish I was as inspired as you are. Who knows what I could create with such inspiration. I am so glad there is a true classical musician on Newgrounds who is willing to offer his musical skill to entertain a snobbish and brutish fellow such as myself.

I give thee a vote of five.

descara responds:

Thanks for the kind words and a funny review, haha. Spent some time on the MIDI to say the least, glad it sounds convincing!

By the way, are you in the RAC as well, or is it just the ADM? If you are, I shudder to think of it!

[Zebra Tangerine {7x}]

At the beginning, it kinda reminds me of the 1990s and when I was a kid. I remember watching the Highlander tv series and this song reminded me of it. But then, the orchestral rock comes in and it takes it to a whole new level.

A very good orchestral rock song, I must say; it gives an epic vibe. You are very talented at what you do.

EbonHawk7X responds:

Thank you! Your piece for the first round was incredible; both you and Samulis are very talented and I'm sure you'll give him a run for his money. I'm really glad you liked the guitar, it took a bunch of tries to get it sounding decent but I guess it paid off!

[King Bosa]

Truly an epic and historical tale that is worthy to be taught in our schools today. I am quite surprised that you are so well versed in Orchestralian and Newgrounds history! Scholastic!

I cannot wait to hear the end of this noble legend. But on a more technical note, I very much enjoyed this piece. You really have developed your own inimitable style, and that is how you succeed in my opinion. I really don't see anything wrong with the structure of the composition, and I can tell you paid close attention to the instruments' detail. However, I feel a lamenting feeling while listening to this -- you portray the realism and truth of the story very well.

samulis responds:

I couldn't resist building around the storyline you presented... I figured my more peaceful style would fit better as a prelude than a continuation... we'll know the results of the war when the round is over!

I find slow sorrowful music is one thing I can do well... violin + signature ridiculous timpani part + something in 7/8 pretty much sums up my style in its distilled form. XD

I guess we got that collaborative project in then... first half here, second half on your page.

Thanks for the review man, can't wait to see what the judges think on these pieces!

[Outside the Atmosphere]

You know, it sort of reminds me of Donkey Kong with the slurs of the classic synth. I'm not well versed in this kind of music, but I must say that the melody is something that will stick in my head for a while :)

OpenLight responds:

Awesome! Out of curiosity (believe me I'm reaaaally happy with the 9/10) what could I do for the 10/10 on this song? I'm always looking to improve.

Thanks for the review! I'm happy to be compared to Donkey Kong music haha.

[Farewell... Grandfather]

I really had no idea you were this good. Wow.

From 0:52 and on, I was completely swept away. I wasn't expecting such a large impact from something so subtle and simple.

5/5 for sure, and feel free to check out my newest track if you find the time to do so.

JosephAS1 responds:

Well I have to say thanks... and I'm really glad that you liked this, even more since I really admire your work quite a lot :D

[Nocturne no. 3]

I am pleasantly surprised by this romantic piece, and your performance thereof. If it indeed you playing, then you deserve recognition as an extremely talented pianist. If you performed this yourself, then you must be classically trained as a pianist.

I very much enjoy your music, and the baroque stye you add to your pieces. You are a great musician, and I do hope that you will continue to produce more music for us to hear!

5/5 stars!

descara responds:

Thank you for your kind words. There'll definitely be more music from me! I've had a bit of training as a pianist, mostly in my younger years though. On a slightly related note (speaking of baroque as well), I'm going to study cembalo and basso continuo playing as a side instrument next Autumn. :)

[The Kingdom (NG-OP 100)]

Are you spanish?

Anyways, after listening to the last part (4:12-5:15) I got the feeling I was watching The Lord of the Rings -- it sounds quite familiar because Howard Shore used the same structure in some of his compositions for the film. I enjoyed your song however, because it had a feeling of chivalry or medieval fantasy that I love.

I could picture this being used in an adventure game like Quest for Glory or King's Quest. You've divided the mix into four parts, and it seems you've blended them well as far as style goes. Using the same instruments and tempo seems to keep the song held together by that strong foundation. Of course the song is digital, but what I'm focused on is the structure, not the quality of the instruments. In fact, I would rather hear this song in an adventure game than a live orchestra. I believe adventure games hold on to a rare novelty with digital music rather than live music.

The song is good as usual. You never cease to impress me with your classical dominance in the audio portal, and you always come up with imaginative storyline to back your songs up. You are a very creative musician and very talented in sequencing and mastering. I very much enjoyed this piece and I cannot wait to hear some more of your excellent stuff.

5/5 - Brotha

samulis responds:

Haha... sadly not, I am American.

I am very glad you liked the piece, I hope to keep improving so one day I might be comparable to you (honestly, it is always a honor to receive a review from you). It seems that my style is better cut for a video game or film score than a symphony or opera and I gladly take that as a sign that I should try to aim for focusing intently on moving into such. If you have any suggestions on what tweaks I can make to better improve my mix or style, I am all ears. :)

I'll keep an eye on your stuff and try to return the favor whenever possible. I always enjoy letting my imagination build on the work of another and providing fodder that might feed a greater work than I could ever conceive.

Many thanks,
-Samulis