Bosa's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Shepherd's Call]

Astounding and Pleasant

Very nice, and the composition reminds me of an arrangement of the Christmas Carol, Noel, in some segments.

I'm very fond of the instrumentation as well, as I often use a Celtic style in my own music. The ensemble of strings with the tin penny and recorder is such a pleasant mixture of instruments to use, and I would like to hear more of your live performances if possible.

Some things are to note, though. During the higher key change, at around 02:17, I would of liked to of heard a short solo of a lower irish whistle transitioning into the key change, instead of you having to hit a lower note. Also, the segment was just a bit too high for me. Of course, my opinion is just personal taste, and I'm not sure if you would agree with my suggestion or not, but there's always room for improvement in everything we create. The pitch is really the only thing that bugged me, and everything else seems flawless in my opinion.

I really liked this performance, as it conveys a mood of returning home to the country, a feeling we all can relate to. I would definitely like to collaborate a piece of music with you some time. Of course if you're up for it, I'm sure we would produce something interesting for the masses to hear.

I will continue to watch your progress with enjoyment, and again I hope to hear more from you.

-Bosa

nathanallenpinard responds:

At the time I only had access to a penny whistle really. I didn't purchase a low irish whistle till this year.

[Melancholy Suite]

Good

Even though this isn't necessarily what I listen to every day, I'm not going to bash you simply because it's not my style of music - that would be ignorant.

Actually, this reminds me a tad bit of a level on Donkey Kong Country 2, as you've used some of the styles of implementation that the composer for Donkey Kong used. It's rather interesting to listen to, and at the moment, I enjoy it very much. Also, the diverse use of electronic sounds makes it very original and polished, that's always good to me.

The only problem I have with it is the volume increase at around 3:10 or so. But, it's not that big of a deal; I was just pointing it out. Honestly, you've produced a fine piece of music and you should be proud of it.

-Bosa

Gorgorothx responds:

Thank you Bosa for the kind words. DKC2 eh? I'll have to look into that and hear it for myself. Cheers for this review!

[Solus- Christmas Lights]

Beautiful

I was actually surprised when I had heard this from you. You've managed to show me that everybody can open their hearts to Christmas and contribute somewhat - even but if a little. I was actually expecting a sudden burst in the middle of the song to a metal, ear pounding rhythm and imagining a Christmas tree being burned down or something. But as I said, you've shown a very good side in this piece and it's very lovely. Your piano work and mere compositions are beautiful.

I know you probably don't like to hear people when they're soft, but this song has truly opened my heart and caused me to look forward to this coming Christmas and it's caused me to appreciate all that has come and shall come to pass. It's caused me to think about the love of my life and how I am going to spend the Christmas with her. Basically, it just causes me to enjoy the life that has been given to me, you're an amazing composer.

I've listened to some of your work and your music brings back memories that I never thought I had. I love your work, and I do hope you will continue to make music as you are now.

SolusLunes responds:

My intent with this song was to bring a tear to someone's eye- and the metal mashing and that wouldn't really fit that image...

This song was, in fact, inspired by the same feeling that this song instilled in you.

Funny how that happens, eh? :D

[Is this Tempo Better?]

ok (what you may remember saying)

I didn't even think that newgrounds allowed these kinda music posts. I'll be honest with you, this was the most junky piece I have ever heard on newgrounds. 1/5 -mrbosa

[Solus- Prima]

Enjoyable!

Once again you've reminded me of a game I used to play (you're really good at this) called the Illusion of Gaia; very nostalgic.

I can tell this wasn't meant to loop, but it seems to flow so well with the silence at the end. You've managed to pull another one under my nose (not a bugger, mind you. I'm a childish loser.)

I can imagine hearing this in a movie with a scene overlooking the rainforest or something similar. Perhaps even a Celtic scene of Ireland or Scotland (because it sounds sorta medieval at the end.) It's just so soothing to listen to.

I love the instruments used in this one, as I can tell you carefully chose them as well. You're just full of musical goodness that I can't help but love your work! I admire you in some ways as you remind me of myself when I was making music a couple of years ago here on Newgrounds.

I do hope you continue making music,
Bosa

SolusLunes responds:

You know, it's really nice to get a review from you, as I've been ninja-listening to every song you've got- I actually never reviewed any of them, and I kind of think that's just kind of rude.

The instrument selection in this song was one of the parts I spent a lot of time on, I'd get to a part where I had finished writing an entire part for an instrument and then deciding "Wow, this sucks balls" and then re-write it (like for the oboe, that went through about four rewrites.)

I will of course keep up making music! :D

[Solus- Last March]

hm... Hm.... HM!?!

I remember a game I used to play back in my early years called Final Fantasy 3. This music matches it almost perfectly as I can now see myself playing the game while listening to it. It loops almost perfectly, and I can surely let you know that your effort was not wasted when spending a lot of time on the trumpet notes and the way it sounds. I can tell that you spent a good while on that instrument alone.

I'm not going to discuss the quality of samples, because I don't really care about samples or real music, or whatnot. What I care about is the score and the way things come together in music. Honestly, I haven't heard music like this in a while - so it's good that there's someone who still fights the good fight (or whatever that means.)

I hope you continue to grow in music and I do hope to hear more from you in the near future,

Bosa

SolusLunes responds:

Ah, good that you're going to ignore the quality of the samples, as it is something that has been niggling on me for a little while, as I've gotten better at composing.

(Though right now I'm currently saving up for a copy of East West. Glee. Sure I could pirate it, but that wouldn't be any different than anyone else, would it?)

The trumpet was spent about... mmm I'd say about four hours just getting the basic melody and another two tweaking it :D

I'm really glad you liked this piece, and as you and MaestroRage say, I will keep fighting the good fight.

Christ, why does everyone feel like using that phrase? :D

[L'Amore Perso (Love Lost)]

Good piece!

This would remind me of a creation by Henning Lohner, Jardin D'Amour. It has that sweet, yet sorrowful sense to it that Henning is always capable of. Perhaps you should do a remake of Jardin D'Amour, yet I don't see it happening because I do not have his score to give you.

On in all, you've managed to pull of a very sad and effective emotional song. I believe this will move many people with its beauty and cunning score, therefore I give you my thumbs up.

p.s. Your author comment is rather interesting. It appears romantic, yet when read deeper, it is rather morbid.

-Bosa

MusicalRocky responds:

Never heard of Henning, but I must check him(her?) out, mustn't I? (Garden of love? Am I right?! Haha). Very true, sweet yet sorrowful indeed. It's all right, I might do a remake by ear :P

Thanks, I'm glad I succeeded in your eyes, Bosa! Thanks for the thumbs up.

True about the author comment. It is pretty depressing :[ Glad you noticed that though, I suppose.

Thanks for the indepth review!
-Rocky

[Laugh At Fat Man]

Excellent!

Excellent work, Lawrie! Mixing piano with guitar always has a soothing effect to the ears. It sounds like it could fit professionally into a light drama - you're something Hollywood needs to look into!

Even though it has a repetitive mood, that doesn't stop me from listening to it again. It seems to drive my mind forward, allowing it to drift into a calm state of being. With practice, you could become very successful in the music business; if you want to, of course.

-Bosa

Lawrie2 responds:

why thanks a lot!

[_-={A Lost Dream}=-_]

Good show!

Excellent work, MaestroRage. Even though it's a little too loud for my ears, the performance was top notch. It actually sounds Mongolian.

Your talents become better with each passing day. I'm also glad to hear you snagged top composer of 07! That's quite an achievement.. more than what I could do ;)

Once again,
Bosa

MaestroRage responds:

Hey Bosa! Long time no see my friend :D! Thank you for dropping by and leaving a review!

I honestly didn't think they were going to have a musician trophy, so it was a rather unexpected surprise! I am told these things are heavy enough to kill people. If they are also finger print resistant, i'm going to go out to town one day ;D!

Once again, thank you for the review, i'm glad you liked it!

[Tokyo Blues]

Well, I have to hand it to ya'

It's a good track overall. It sounds like a rehearsal session rather than an actual performance.. no offense intended. You're making a good start by submitting a live performance and I'm sure you'll get far here on the audio portal if you keep on practicing!

It's better than what I can do jazz-wise,
Bosa

RadioactiveRhino responds:

Thank you Bosa! And as for the rehearsal session, that sorta is what it is. So, that means it turned out well :P

And hearing that last line from you means alot.
I'm putting that in my imaginary online NG scrapbook!